Fiction Profits Academy Review – Is It Legit?

Hey, it’s Mark from MarksInsights.

If you’ve seen Fiction Profits Academy online, you’ve probably watched Karla Marie talk about making money on Amazon by publishing fiction books you didn’t write yourself.

The pitch is simple: use ghostwriters, follow her system, and earn passive royalties month after month.

It sounds appealing, especially if you like the idea of earning from Amazon without being an author. But as with most online publishing programs, there’s a lot more going on behind the scenes than what’s shown in the ads.

In this review, I’ll break down what Fiction Profits Academy actually teaches, how the business model works, what it costs, the real challenges involved, and finally whether it’s worth your money.

Before we dive in..

After 15 years of testing every way to make money online, I’ve seen what works and what’s a complete waste of time.

If I had to start from scratch today, there’s only one business model I’d choose.

It’s simple, scalable, and works even if you’re a total beginner.

👉 Click here to check out my No.1 recommendation

Key Takeaways (If you are in a hurry!)

• Fiction Profits Academy is a course by Karla Marie that teaches how to build a fiction publishing business on Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP).
• While marketed as beginner-friendly, the content is better suited for experienced self-publishers who already understand the basics.
• The refund policy exists, but it has strict conditions, and some students reported challenges in getting their money back.
• Reddit feedback is overwhelmingly critical, citing misleading marketing, upsells, hidden costs, and pressure tactics.
• VERDICT: Fiction Profits Academy is legit, but the real costs, effort, and risk involved make it a tough sell for beginners.

RECOMMENDED: 👉 Click here to check out my no.1 alternative program

What is Fiction Profits Academy?

Fiction Profits Academy is a program created by Karla Marie that teaches you how to build a business self-publishing fiction books on Amazon, mainly through Kindle Direct Publishing, which is Amazon’s platform for eBooks.

She teaches you how to generate a stream of income by tapping into popular fiction markets, even if you’ve never written a book in your life.

Now, who is Karla Marie?

She didn’t start off in publishing. She was a musician and visual artist traveling around Canada before jumping into the eBook space. When the lifestyle wore her out, she started publishing fiction to see if she could make money from home, and she cracked the code.

She’s now published over 60 fiction books herself, earns multiple six figures a year doing it, and has taught thousands of others through Fiction Profits Academy.

One of the big things she emphasizes is that you don’t need to be a writer to make this work. You don’t need a lot of money to start, either. No inventory. No office. No employees. If you’ve got a laptop, internet, and a willingness to figure it out, you’re technically good to go.

But let’s be clear: this isn’t magic. Just because there’s automation doesn’t mean it’s passive from day one. You still have to research the markets, test book concepts, manage freelancers, and learn how Amazon’s algorithm works. There’s definitely a learning curve.

That said, if the idea of building a fiction book business using tools and systems instead of sitting down and writing 300 pages by hand sounds interesting to you, that’s what this course is trying to teach you to do.

I am going to look at what you ACTUALLY can expect from this course because what Karla says and what you will get are two different things. But before I blow the lid off this program, let me walk you through what this course offers.

RECOMMENDED: 👉 Click here to check out my No.1 recommendation

How Does Fiction Profits Academy Work?

The cost of joining Fiction Profits Academy is $2,000 and the bootcamp can go for $750 (please re-check the prices because they may change before you read this).

But after you watch the webinar and decide to join, here’s how it works:

• You start by identifying fiction niches that are already selling well on Amazon—think romance, sci-fi, thrillers, fantasy, that sort of thing.
• You either write short novels yourself or outsource the writing to ghostwriters (she shows you how to do both).
• Then you publish them through Kindle Direct Publishing and list them for sale.
• Once you start making sales, the plan is to repeat the process and gradually build a catalog of books. Eventually, the goal is to have enough revenue to outsource everything—writing, cover design, even marketing—and scale it into a hands-off business.

Now, all of this is packed into a 10-module course that walks you through each step. It starts with the basics: how to come up with story ideas, how to create covers that actually catch people’s eyes, and how to list everything properly on Amazon.

Then it moves into more advanced stuff like market research, using AI tools, finding and managing ghostwriters, and building a long-term brand that keeps bringing in sales.

What makes it a bit different is how automation-heavy it is. You’re taught to use AI to brainstorm, test ideas, and generate content. It’s not about writing the next great novel—it’s more about learning what sells and building a system that puts out books people are already looking for.

This is also where the marketing leans heavily on AI — brainstorming ideas, drafting scenes, optimising concepts. But, as I outline in my AI Hype vs Reality article, AI tools can support your workflow, not replace the hard parts. They don’t remove the need for editors, ghostwriters, market research, or a real understanding of reader psychology.

AI adds convenience, not passive income.

RECOMMENDED: 👉 Click here to check out my No.1 recommendation

What Do You REALLY Get with Fiction Profits Academy?

I am always apprehensive about spending thousands of dollars on a course, and I want to be sure that what I pay for is what I get.

Is that the case with Karla’s FPA?

Well, for starters, Karla promises a system that shows you how to make money by publishing fiction eBooks on Amazon’s Kindle Direct Publishing platform.

In her video pitch, Karla makes it sound easy: pick a profitable niche, get someone to write a book for you (unless you want to write it yourself, which most people don’t), then publish it and watch the royalties roll in.

Now, I’ll give her that. When you buy into the program, you’re getting access to a structured course that breaks down how to build a fiction publishing “business.” That includes:

• How to hire ghostwriters (through places like Upwork)
• Getting book covers made
• Publishing on Amazon
• Promoting through email lists and possibly ads

It all sounds great on paper until you realize the true cost of involved here.

Although publishing on Amazon is technically a real online business, it’s important to compare it to other paths. As I explain in my How to Make Money Online guide, the opportunities that stand the test of time are the ones built on clear business fundamentals, not romantic ideas of passive royalties.

Publishing can work, but it’s far from passive, the margins are tight, and the upfront costs are heavy. Most beginners don’t realise they’re stepping into a full content-production business, not a simple “upload and earn” model.

The Actual Costs Involved

Karla says in the webinar that it costs around $250 to produce a book (ghostwriting + cover).

There’s even this breakdown in the FAQ section at the bottom of the website that states:

“If you’re just starting out, we suggest beginning with shorter books (10,000 to 30,000 words). The cost for ghostwriting these books ranges between $100 and $300, based on a rate of about $0.01 per word.”

Then it continues:

“As you gain experience and start seeing returns, we recommend transitioning to longer books of about 30,000 to 50,00 words, typically costing around $300 to $500.”

Those numbers get tossed around like it’s standard, but once you’re inside, you start realizing that nobody is producing books at that price point and succeeding.

This is where Fiction Profits Academy becomes very different from other business models. In my guide comparing Online Business Models, I break down the costs and timelines of each model and publishing consistently falls into the “high upfront investment, slow ROI” category.

You’re not just buying a course. You’re stepping into a model that requires continuous reinvestment into ghostwriting, editing, covers, and ads. If you’re not prepared for that, you’ll burn cash fast.

Realistically, you’re looking at $1000 to $1200 per book if you’re hiring a decent ghostwriter, paying for editing, cover design, and maybe some promo.

Another thing you should know is that in order to follow their blueprint for success, you’re expected to crank out a book a month. That means you’ll be sinking several thousand dollars into this before you even start seeing a return. And that’s on top of the price of joining the program itself!

Early on, they’ll get you on a call with your so-called “personal success coach.”

The coach will ask you a few questions about your goals, tell to watch the course modules, and then offer you a special opportunity to apply for Bootcamp: a $750-ish upsell for extra 1:1 help. I don’t know what you make of it but that sounds to me like a sales call wrapped in a pep talk.

What About Refunds?

And let’s talk about the refund. You see the money-back guarantee and you think, okay, at least I’ve got that as a safety net. But buried in the fine print (which they don’t exactly shout from the rooftops), there are conditions.

You have to:

• Watch all the modules (there are about 8)
• Publish a “lead magnet” book
• Publish your first full book within 30 days

Only then do you even qualify for the refund. If you don’t meet those steps, tough luck. They may not even reply to your emails.

I should make it clear: they will refund you (and that’s not always the case with online courses).

Now, I’ve seen some people complain that they had to chase them a bit for the refund and then they just processed it silently and paid them back.

Also, there’s this pressure to upgrade fast. I initially felt pushed toward the Bootcamp. Without it, and without hiring ghostwriters and editors, you’re basically swimming upstream. I tried doing everything on my own for a month to cut costs, but it ate up more time, energy, and stress than it was worth.

At that point, you start feeling like your only option is to throw more money at the process.

Is it worth it?

Well, you do get a course that teaches you a structured method to make money with Kindle fiction books. But the marketing is misleading, the startup costs are way higher than advertised, and the refund policy feels like a trap. The whole setup draws in people who might already be stretched thin financially and then pushes them deeper into a system that keeps demanding more.

It’s not that it can’t work; it can. There are people getting results. But if you’re going to go down this path, do it with your eyes wide open. The profit potential exists, but it comes with big upfront costs, a steep learning curve, and a good dose of pressure to spend more. Don’t expect magic. Expect work. And budget more than they tell you—a lot more.

RECOMMENDED: 👉 Click here to check out my No.1 recommendation

Who is Fiction Profits Academy For?

I know Karla takes all comers and even encourages anyone to try out her course.

But in my opinion?

Fiction Profits Academy isn’t really designed for someone just dipping their toes into Amazon Kindle Publishing for the first time. If you’re brand new, meaning you haven’t published a book, don’t know what a lead magnet is, or haven’t played around with keywords or ad targeting, I liken this to jumping into the deep end without floaties.

That’s not to say you couldn’t find value in it, but the course works best if you’ve got the basics already figured out.

The kind of person who might get the most out of Fiction Profits Academy is someone who’s already been in the self-publishing trenches for a while: You’ve set up funnels, you’ve collected emails, you’ve run ads even if they were too expensive to scale, or you’ve written a bunch of books or novellas and you know how to finish a draft without needing your hand held.

Now, if you’ve done all that groundwork and you still feel like you’re missing something, you can give FPA a try.

You might be doing all the right things on paper (writing solid stories, packaging them decently, setting up the backend stuff) but it’s not converting like it should. That’s the gap this course seems to speak to.

You’re not looking for a hand-holding beginner guide. You want:

• The right keywords that surface your book in front of buyers.
• The right tropes that hit the emotional beats readers love.
• Covers that sell even if you can’t make them yourself.
• Blurbs that hook readers fast enough to click ‘Buy Now.’
• Profitable series ideas, especially short interconnected ones that lead to page reads and read-throughs.

I’d say you are in the perfect position to try FPA if you’re already writing your own stuff and doing the editing yourself because you’re in a solid position to move fast (assuming you’ve got direction on what to write and how to frame it).

Cost is also a major factor. If you’re operating on a tight margin, the idea of dropping a large amount on coaching or tools feels like taking a loan you’re not sure you can repay. It’s not that you don’t believe in your ability to execute, but the risk of digging deeper into debt isn’t a small thing. You’d probably jump on this if money wasn’t a barrier.

Ultimately, I’d say Fiction Profits Academy is for the experienced self-publisher who’s already been hustling on KDP but hasn’t cracked the formula yet. Someone who’s not starting from zero and is somewhere between knowing what should work and making it work consistently.

RECOMMENDED: 👉 Click here to check out my No.1 recommendation

What Are People Saying About Fiction Profits Academy on Reddit?

When someone asked “Is Fiction Profits Academy actually legit?” on r/FictionWriting, one commenter who had joined summed it up bluntly: “BUYER BEWARE.” They noted the program teaches, but it leans heavily on deceptive marketing because it doesn’t reveal the true cost of publishing.

There’s a consistent vibe that the program is oversold to people with little capital. One user described how the “personal success coach” was just a salesperson upselling a pricey boot camp rather than offering real coaching. They did get a refund eventually, but only after being ignored on communication.

Across other subs like r/selfpublish and r/KDP, the sentiment gets even sharper. One person who’d worked with clients from Fiction Profits Academy said it was “a nightmare” and that they had to literally teach clients what a romance novel is.

Another warned it’s basically a grift wrapped in pseudo-authenticity: yes, there’s some truth to making money via Kindle publishing or ghostwriting, but you certainly don’t need a pricey “academy” to figure it out—you can Google it yourself.

One commenter on r/passive_income went further, calling it a classic guru funnel: get you in cheap, then upsell and cash in on every step—including your ghostwriters and editors—with vague or misleading promises. They even shared a horror story about losing $8,000, getting locked into ghostwriter/legal obligations, and being blocked if they tried to voice complaints in the community group.

On the flip side, platforms like Trustpilot and BBB show high ratings with massive review counts.

But Redditors point out these are often curated or paid testimonials, and there’s minimal independent evidence of real publishing success or verified author income from students.

So overall, the Reddit consensus is pretty blunt: people see Fiction Profits Academy as a high-cost, high-risk proposition.

RECOMMENDED: 👉 Click here to check out my No.1 recommendation

Pros of Fiction Profits Academy

Potential for Success

The program may work if you know a bit about writing self-publishing and you are struggling to bring everything together. It gives you a blueprint that you can learn from and use to connect the dots in your own way.

Money-Back Guarantee

Yes, you will get a refund if you apply for it and have met the criteria. They will actually send your money back, which is something that you can’t say about many online programs.

Positive Feedback

Many people online have talked about the expertise and personalized advice provided by coaches. The community aspect has also been a plus because it brings together people who write.

Cons of Fiction Profits Academy

Deceptive Marketing

I am concerned about their deceptive marketing tactics, such as minimizing the effort and costs involved in self-publishing.

Hidden Costs

I don’t think what they tell us about the cost of the program reflects the true expenses, which can include hiring writers, editors, purchasing book covers, and marketing.

Difficulty Obtaining Refunds

Some users have reported issues with obtaining refunds, particularly for the Bootcamp program.

Unrealistic Expectations

In my opinion, Karla is promising unrealistic results regarding passive income and passive profits from book sales.

Is Fiction Profits Academy Legit?

Yes, Fiction Profits Academy is legit in the sense that you do receive a full course, tools, and community. On the surface, it looks like a solid step-by-step program for launching a self-publishing business through Amazon KDP.

But here’s the reality most people don’t see upfront:

Karla Marie clearly understands KDP, but it’s difficult to verify her own publishing success. There isn’t a public track record of bestselling fiction linked to her name, which raises the question of where the bulk of her income actually comes from — the books or the course itself.

The pitch also downplays the true costs. The marketing suggests you can get started with a couple of books for around $500, but a realistic budget is closer to $1,000+ per book once you factor in ghostwriting, editing, covers, and marketing. And if you want books that actually sell? Costs go even higher.

Another issue is how “passive” the model is framed. Self-publishing can work, but it’s far from hands-off. You’ll be dealing with market research, managing freelancers, optimizing keywords, building a brand, and learning Amazon’s algorithm — none of which happens automatically.

So no, Fiction Profits Academy isn’t a scam. The model itself is real. But it’s also far more expensive, time-intensive, and complicated than the marketing suggests. If you join, go in with realistic expectations rather than hoping for easy passive income.

This is also something I’ve seen with other publishing courses like the Mikkelsen Twins’ Publishing program, where the coaching ecosystem generates far more income than the actual publishing method.

A Better Alternative to Fiction Profits Academy

If you were drawn to Fiction Profits Academy because you want a real online income—not endless learning curves, not heavy costs, not “hit or miss” royalties—then there’s a far better path.

And it’s the one I recommend above everything else.

Local Lead Generation (My No.1 Recommendation)

Instead of spending thousands on ghostwriters, editors, covers, and ads… local lead generation flips the script entirely.

1. You build simple websites targeting local service niches.
2. People search on Google.
3. Your site ranks (either organically or with low-cost paid ads).
4. The leads go straight to a local business… and you get paid $500–$2,000/month per site.

• No fiction writing.
• No Amazon algorithm.
• No expensive production costs.
• No hoping your book “takes off.”

Just predictable leads → predictable monthly income.

It’s simple, scalable, and genuinely beginner-friendly — which is why it’s my no.1 recommendation.

👉 Click here to discover my No.1 recommendation