Herbalife Review: Can You Really Make Money in 2026?

If you’re researching Herbalife as a business opportunity, you’ve probably heard both the success stories and the controversies. On one side, you see testimonials of people making six figures. On the other, you hear warnings about MLM pyramid schemes and the $200 million FTC settlement Herbalife paid in 2016.

The truth about Herbalife’s income opportunity is best found in their own income disclosure statement, which they’re legally required to publish.

Here’s what you need to know before joining Herbalife as an Independent Distributor: according to Herbalife’s 2024 U.S. income disclosure, 50% of distributors who earned money made less than $268 per month before expenses. For first-year distributors, that number drops to just $154 per month.

More tellingly, out of approximately 113,000 U.S. distributors who ordered products for resale in 2024, only about 50,600 (45%) actually earned any money in a typical month. The majority—meaning over half—earned nothing at all during most months.

Does that mean Herbalife is a scam? No—it’s a legitimate publicly-traded company with $4.9 billion in annual revenue. But is it a realistic way to build income for most people? Personally I think there are better ways.

A More Reliable Path to Building Income

Before diving into the detailed analysis of Herbalife’s compensation plan, let me be direct: if your goal is building reliable monthly income without buying inventory or recruiting friends and family, there’s a better option.

Local lead generation lets you build income-generating assets—websites that rank on Google for local service searches—and rent leads to businesses for $500-$2,000 per month.

👉 Click here to learn how I build recurring income without MLM

Here’s the difference:

• Herbalife: Median distributor earns $268/month before expenses (and that’s only those who earned anything)
• Local lead gen: Each site generates $500-$2,000/month recurring revenue

Herbalife: Need inventory, samples, attend meetings, recruit downline Local lead gen: No inventory, no recruiting, minimal expenses ($10/month hosting)

Herbalife: Income depends on personal sales + team performance Local lead gen: You own the asset completely, full control

Herbalife: 55% of active distributors earn $0 in typical month Local lead gen: If site ranks and has client, you earn predictably

I currently own 12 lead gen sites generating $8,500/month combined. No shakes to sell, no nutrition clubs to run, no recruiting. Just websites generating leads that businesses pay for monthly.

👉 Click here to learn how I build recurring income without MLM

Key Takeaways

• What it is: Herbalife is a multi-level marketing company selling nutrition, weight management, and personal care products through Independent Distributors
• Founded: 1980 by Mark Hughes in Los Angeles
• Revenue: $4.9 billion globally (2024)
• Products: Formula 1 shakes, protein supplements, energy drinks, skincare, vitamins
• Active U.S. distributors who ordered for resale: ~113,000 (2024)
• Median monthly earnings (those who earned anything): $268 before expenses
• First-year median: $154/month before expenses
• Percentage earning nothing in typical month: 55% (of those ordering for resale)
• FTC settlement: $200 million (2016) for deceptive business practices
• Compensation: Retail margin + bonuses based on personal and team volume
• My verdict: Legitimate company, but compensation structure makes it nearly impossible for average person to earn meaningful income

👉 RECOMMENDED: See the business model I actually recommend

What Is Herbalife?

Herbalife Nutrition Ltd. is a global multi-level marketing company that sells nutritional supplements, weight management products, and personal care items through a network of Independent Distributors. Founded in 1980 by Mark Hughes, the company is headquartered in Los Angeles and publicly traded on the New York Stock Exchange (ticker: HLF).

The Product Lines

Formula 1 Nutritional Shake Mix: Herbalife’s flagship product, meal replacement shake in various flavors

Targeted Nutrition: Vitamins, minerals, herbal supplements

Weight Management: Protein bars, snacks, metabolism support

Energy & Fitness: Herbalife24 sports nutrition line, energy drinks

Outer Nutrition: Skincare and personal care products

Products are premium-priced compared to similar offerings at retail stores. For example, Formula 1 shake costs $46.29 (distributor price) and retails for $59.95, while comparable meal replacement shakes at Walmart or Amazon cost $20-$35.

How Herbalife Works

As an Independent Distributor, you make money through:

1. Retail Profit: Buy products at distributor discount (typically 25%), sell at retail price, keep the difference

2. Wholesale Profit: Sell to “preferred customers” at slight markup over your distributor cost

3. Royalty Overrides and Bonuses: Earn commissions based on your “downline” team’s sales volume (multi-level structure)

The emphasis, like most MLMs, is on building a team. While you can earn retail margin selling products, meaningful income requires recruiting others who also recruit.

The Controversial History

Herbalife has faced significant legal and regulatory scrutiny:

2016 FTC Settlement: Paid $200 million to settle charges of deceptive business practices and misrepresenting income potential. Required to restructure compensation plan.

Pyramid scheme allegations: Activist investor Bill Ackman famously bet $1 billion against Herbalife in 2012, calling it a pyramid scheme. While Herbalife survived, the controversy highlighted structural concerns.

China controversy: Repeatedly fined and investigated in China for operating illegally as pyramid scheme before restructuring to comply.

These controversies don’t make Herbalife illegal, but they reveal serious questions about how the business actually operates.

The Compensation Plan Breakdown

Herbalife’s compensation plan is complex, with multiple ways distributors can theoretically earn money.

Retail Profit (Direct Sales)

Purchase products at 25% discount (initially), sell at suggested retail price, keep the difference.

Example (from Herbalife’s disclosure):

• Suggested retail price: $59.95
• Distributor price: $46.29
• Potential profit: $13.66

Reality: Selling at full retail price is difficult when customers can find similar products cheaper online or at stores. Most distributors don’t achieve significant retail sales.

Wholesale Profit

Sell products to “preferred customers” at prices between your distributor cost and full retail. Margins are lower but easier to sell.

Reality: This typically generates just a few dollars profit per sale.

Royalty Overrides (Team Commissions)

This is where the MLM structure kicks in. Earn percentage commissions on your downline’s sales volume.

Structure:

• Recruit distributors into your “downline”
• Earn royalty overrides based on their product purchases
• Earn on multiple levels (your recruits’ recruits, etc.)
• Higher volume = higher percentage royalties

Reality: Most people you recruit will quit (MLM attrition is typically 50-80% annually). Building and maintaining a productive team is extremely difficult.

Production Bonuses

Additional bonuses based on monthly volume from your organization.

Reality: Requires significant team volume to qualify.

Recognition Levels

Herbalife has a complex recognition system:

• Distributor (entry level)
• Senior Consultant
• Success Builder
• Qualified Producer
• Supervisor
• World Team
• Global Expansion Team
• Millionaire Team
• President’s Team
• Founder’s Circle

Higher levels sound impressive, but reaching them requires extraordinary recruitment and team building. Less than 1% of distributors reach upper levels.

The Income Reality: What Herbalife’s Own Data Shows

Let’s examine Herbalife’s 2024 U.S. income disclosure—the numbers they’re legally required to publish after the FTC settlement.

The Full Picture

Total U.S. distributors who ordered products for resale in 2024: ~113,000

Distributors who earned money from sales: ~102,000

Distributors who earned money in a typical month: ~50,600 (45% of those ordering for resale)

This means 55% of distributors who ordered products for resale earned $0 in a typical month.

Median Monthly Earnings (Those Who Earned Anything)

First-Year Distributors:

• Total: ~6,000 who earned in typical month
• 50% earned more than $154/month before expenses
• Top 10% earned more than $1,144/month
• Top 1% earned more than $5,389/month
• About half earned in five months or more (meaning half earned in fewer than five months)

All Other Distributors (Beyond First Year):

• Total: ~44,600 who earned in typical month
• 50% earned more than $268/month before expenses
• Top 10% earned more than $4,982/month
• Top 1% earned more than $19,679/month
• About half earned in six months or more (meaning half earned in fewer than six months)

What “Before Expenses” Means

These earnings are before typical distributor expenses:

• Initial Business Pack: $54.95
• Product inventory: Distributors often buy $100-$500+/month in products
• Samples and demonstrations: $50-$200/month
• Marketing materials: $20-$100/month
• Nutrition club expenses (if running one): Rent, utilities, licenses = $500-$2,000+/month
• Travel to events/meetings: $100-$500/month
• Training and events: $200-$1,000+/year

Conservative estimate: $200-$500/month in expenses for active distributors trying to build a business.

Reality check: If median earnings are $268/month before expenses, and typical expenses are $200-$500/month, most distributors are losing money or breaking even at best.

The Top 1% Reality

The top 1% (~445 distributors) earned more than $19,679/month. That sounds impressive until you realize:

• Tenure: Top 1% typically had 5-11 years in the business
• Percentage: Only 1% (about 445 out of 50,600) reach this level
• Still before expenses: Even top earners have significant business expenses

The Truth About “Typical” Earnings

Herbalife’s disclosure carefully states these are earnings in a “typical month” for those who earned. But notice:

• First-year distributors earned in only five months or more (about half)
• Other distributors earned in six months or more (about half)

This means many “active” distributors go multiple months earning nothing, then occasionally earn small amounts.

Pros and Cons

Let me provide balanced assessment.

What Works in Herbalife’s Favor

Legitimate Company: 45+ years in business, publicly traded, $4.9 billion revenue

Recognized Brand: Well-known globally with some loyal customers

Quality Control: Products are manufactured to standards and tested

Low Initial Cost: $54.95 to join (though ongoing costs add up)

Flexibility: Work your own schedule

Some People Do Succeed: A tiny percentage (top 1-5%) genuinely earn good income

Training Available: Company provides product and business training

What Doesn’t Hold Up

Median Income is Terrible: $268/month before expenses for those who earn anything

55% Earn Nothing: In a typical month, over half of active distributors make $0

Income Before Expenses Misleading: Most break even or lose money after expenses

Requires Team Building: Can’t build meaningful income without recruiting downline

Expensive Products: Difficult to compete with retail alternatives

FTC Settlement History: $200 million paid for deceptive practices

High Attrition: Most recruits quit, requiring constant recruiting

Time Intensive: Building to profitable levels takes years (top 1% averaged 5-11 years)

Nutrition Club Pressure: Many are encouraged to open nutrition clubs requiring significant investment and risk

Why Local Lead Generation Is Better

Comparing Herbalife to other MLM opportunities like Amway or Natura & Co, the income reality is similar: most participants earn little to nothing while a tiny percentage at the top profit from the structure.

If you’re considering Herbalife because you want to build your own business and generate monthly income, local lead generation offers everything Herbalife promises—but actually delivers.

Income Comparison

Herbalife median: $268/month before expenses (and only 45% earn anything in typical month) One lead gen site: $500-$2,000/month after minimal expenses

Herbalife path to $5,000/month: Recruit and manage large team, work for years, reach top 5-10%, maybe hit this level after 3-5+ years Lead gen path to $5,000/month: Build 5-8 sites over 12-18 months

No Inventory or Product Purchases Required

Herbalife: Distributors often buy $100-$500+/month in products to:

• Maintain personal volume requirements
• Have inventory to sell
• Provide samples
• “Be a product of the product” (cultural pressure)

Lead generation: Zero product purchases. Just build websites.

No Recruiting Required

Herbalife’s compensation structure requires building a downline. That means:

• Recruiting friends and family
• Managing team dynamics
• Dealing with 50-80% annual attrition
• Constant pressure to recruit
• Awkward social situations

Lead generation: Build sites alone. No recruiting. No team management. No relationship strain.

You Own the Assets

Herbalife: You’re an independent contractor. Herbalife can:

• Change commission structures (they did after FTC settlement)
• Modify compensation plans
• Adjust product prices
• Change qualification requirements
• You don’t own anything except unsold inventory

Lead generation: You own the websites completely. No company can change your earnings or terms. Can sell sites for 15-25x monthly earnings.

Predictable Income

Herbalife income depends on:

• Your personal sales (variable, requires constant prospecting)
• Your team’s sales (can’t control)
• Team retention (most quit)
• Seasonal fluctuations
• You earning in only 5-6 months per year for many

Lead generation income:

• Once site ranks and client is signed, income is predictable monthly
• Client pays $1,000/month? That continues unless they cancel (rare)
• Not dependent on recruiting or others’ performance

Lower Expenses, Higher Margins

Herbalife expenses:

• Product purchases: $100-$500+/month
• Samples: $50-$200/month
• Events/training: $200-$1,000+/year
• Marketing materials
• Travel
• Nutrition club expenses (if applicable): $500-$2,000+/month
• Total: $200-$3,000+/month

Lead gen expenses:

• Hosting: $10/month per site
• Total: $10/month

Real Example

Herbalife path: Join for $55, buy products monthly, recruit friends/family, attend meetings, run nutrition club (maybe), work 15-25 hours/week for years… maybe earn $3,000-5,000/month if you’re in the top 5-10%.

Lead gen path: Build 4 sites over 6-9 months ($200 investment), rank them, rent each for $1,000/month = $4,000/month recurring. Total time: 80-120 hours upfront, then 4-6 hours/month maintenance.

The ROI comparison is stark.

👉 Learn how to build real recurring income without inventory or recruiting

Common Questions

Is Herbalife a pyramid scheme?

Legally, no—Herbalife restructured after the 2016 FTC settlement to focus more on retail sales vs. recruitment. However, the practical reality is that meaningful income still comes from building a downline team, not from retail sales. The structure resembles a pyramid even if it’s technically legal.

Can you really make money with Herbalife?

Some people do, but the odds are terrible. Herbalife’s own data shows 55% of active distributors earn $0 in a typical month. Of those who earn anything, 50% make less than $268/month before expenses. Less than 1% earn enough to replace a full-time job.

How much does it cost to join Herbalife?

Initial Business Pack costs $54.95. However, ongoing costs are significant: product purchases ($100-$500+/month), samples, marketing materials, events, training. If you open a nutrition club, add $500-$2,000+/month in rent, utilities, and licenses.

Do you have to buy inventory?

No formal requirement, but there’s heavy pressure to maintain “personal volume” and be a “product of the product.” Most active distributors buy $100-$500+/month in products whether or not they’re selling them.

What’s a nutrition club?

A physical location where distributors serve Herbalife shakes and teas to customers. Many are encouraged to open these, but they require significant investment (rent, utilities, licenses) and most lose money. Herbalife earns from product sales to these clubs regardless of whether they profit.

Why do people stay in Herbalife if they’re not making money?

Psychological factors: sunk cost fallacy (already invested money/time), belief that success is “just around the corner,” social pressure from upline, and the community aspect. Also, some genuinely love the products and treat it as a discount club, not a business.

My Honest Verdict

Herbalife is a legitimate company selling real products. It’s not an illegal pyramid scheme after the FTC settlement restructuring. But is it a realistic way to build meaningful income? For 95%+ of people, absolutely not.

The data is crystal clear:

• 55% of active distributors earn $0 in a typical month
• Median earnings for those who earn: $268/month before expenses
• After expenses, most are breaking even or losing money
• Less than 1% earn enough to replace full-time income
• Top earners typically spent 5-11 years building

Who might succeed with Herbalife:

• Exceptional salespeople comfortable with aggressive recruiting
• People with large existing networks willing to join
• Those who genuinely love the products and don’t mind minimal income
• People treating it as a social club, not income source
• Those with capital to open nutrition clubs and patience for 3-5+ year timelines

Who should avoid Herbalife:

• Anyone seeking reliable income (55% earn nothing in typical month)
• People uncomfortable recruiting friends and family
• Those without $2,000-$5,000/year to spend on a “business opportunity”
• Anyone wanting to own their business (you’re a contractor for Herbalife)
• People who can’t afford to lose money for 1-2+ years while “building”

The bottom line: When Herbalife’s own income disclosure shows 55% of active distributors earning $0 in a typical month, and the median for those who earn anything is $268/month before expenses, the math doesn’t work for the vast majority.

If you want to build a real business with recurring income, asset ownership, and predictable growth—without inventory, recruiting, or managing a downline—local lead generation offers everything Herbalife promises but actually delivers.

👉 Click here to build a real business you actually own